Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Forensic Heading / Aliases | Judith Defour (Judith Cullinder) |
| Legal Identity | Judith Defour |
| Confirmed Victims | 1 (Mary Defour, her 2-year-old daughter) |
| Active Timeline | January 1734 |
| Jurisdiction / Area of Operations | Bethnal Green / Spitalfields, London, United Kingdom |
| Criminological Classification | Filicide motivated by economic gain and substance addiction (Gin Craze) |
| Forensic Modus Operandi | Administrative fraud to extract child from workhouse, stripping of garments, manual strangulation via linen handkerchief, and abandonment in a ditch to procure funds for alcohol |
| Weapon / Mechanism of Death | Manual strangulation using a linen rag/handkerchief |
| Motive / Behavioral Dynamics | Severe alcohol addiction and extreme destitution amid 18th-century London's 'Gin Craze' |
| Judicial Outcome | Sentenced to death at the Old Bailey on February 27, 1734; executed by hanging at Tyburn on March 8, 1734 |
1. Background and Psychopathy
Judith Defour was born around 1701 in London. She worked as a silk throwster within the impoverished working-class districts of the British capital during the early 18th century. Her life was characterized by severe socioeconomic hardship and profound alcohol dependency, occurring against the historical backdrop of the 'Gin Craze'—an era when the rampant consumption of cheap gin devastated London's lower strata. Due to her inability to support her illegitimate daughter, Mary Defour (born from her relationship with a weaver named John Cullender), Judith had placed the child in the parish workhouse of Bethnal Green.
2. Crime Spree
In late January 1734, driven by an urgent craving for alcohol, Defour formulated a criminal plan. Using a fraudulent note mimicking the authorization of parish wardens, she deceived workhouse officials on Sunday, January 27, 1734, obtaining temporary custody of two-year-old Mary, who had been provided with newly minted parish clothes just days prior.
Accompanied by an accomplice known only as Sukey (Susannah), Judith led the toddler into secluded fields near Bethnal Green. There, they stripped the child of her garments and tightly bound a linen handkerchief around her neck to stifle her cries, leaving her lifeless body in a drainage ditch. Immediately afterward, they sold the infant's clothing to a receiver of stolen goods for sixteen pence (a shilling and a groat), splitting the proceeds to purchase portions of gin.
3. Crime Spree and Forensic Hunt
The child's body was discovered shortly thereafter in a ditch in the fields of Bethnal Green by local residents, who observed distinct ligature marks and signs of strangulation on the victim's neck. Eyewitnesses reported seeing three women lingering near the crime scene. Police and community inquiries quickly traced the movements back to Defour's workplace. Coworkers, including Elizabeth Scot and Susan Jones, noted Judith's erratic behavior; she cryptically confessed to having done something worthy of Newgate Prison and having left her child exposed in the freezing fields. This pressure led directly to official reporting.
4. Arrest and Judicial Proceedings
Judith Defour was arrested in late January 1734 (January 29–30). During interrogations before Justice of the Peace Anthony Chamberlain, Defour confessed to the crime while attempting to shift primary responsibility onto her accomplice, Sukey. She was tried at the Old Bailey sessions on February 27, 1734, indicted for murder and infanticide.
During the proceedings, Defour attempted to plead her belly to stay execution through presumed pregnancy, but a jury of matrons inspected her and declared her not pregnant. The court returned a guilty verdict and sentenced her to death.
5. Psychiatric Assessment and Outcome
Judith Defour's case stands as a grim criminological emblem of the brutality wrought by chronic alcoholism during England's 'Gin Craze', serving as a moral cautionary tale reflected in William Hogarth's famous engravings ('Gin Lane') and contemporary philanthropic efforts by figures like Thomas Coram. Although her mother testified that Defour suffered from chronic mental instability, the court established full criminal accountability. On March 8, 1734, Judith Defour was conveyed to Tyburn gallows, where her death sentence was carried out by hanging.




