CRIMETECATrue Crime Archive
DossiersCasesCompareForumMapStats
/
Sign In
CRIMETECA

The definitive digital archive of True Crime, forensic criminology, and serial killers. Historical preservation of over 7,300 criminal records worldwide.

7,344 Verified Cases•+12,000 Photographs

Navigation

  • Case Dossiers
  • Crime Cases
  • Forensic Statistics
  • Comparador Forense
  • Community & Forum

Documentary Notice

Platform intended for academic research, criminology journalism, and historical preservation. No criminal act is promoted or glorified.

© 2026 Crimeteca. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of UsePress Inquiries
Back to archive
Lemuel Smith
Imprisoned
Download Dossier (PDF)Discuss in Forum
Forensic Case Timeline

Chronological reconstruction of crimes, breakthrough clues, police capture, and judicial outcome.

21 de enero de 1958The CrimeAmsterdam, New York
Verified Forensic Milestone

Murder of Dorothy Waterstreet

Dorothy Waterstreet is robbed and beaten to death in Amsterdam, New York.

24 de noviembre de 1976The CrimeAlbany, New York
Verified Forensic Milestone

Double murder at religious store

Robert Hedderman and Margaret Byron are murdered in Albany.

19 de agosto de 1977Raid & ArrestSchenectady, New York
Verified Forensic Milestone

Arrest for kidnapping

Smith is arrested following the kidnapping and rape of Marianne Maggio.

15 de mayo de 1981The CrimeStormville, New York
Verified Forensic Milestone

Murder of Donna Payant

Smith murders corrections officer Donna Payant at Green Haven.

10 de junio de 1983Trial & SentencingDutchess County, New York
Verified Forensic Milestone

Death sentence

Smith is formally sentenced to death for the murder of Payant.

Theater of Operations

Forensic Cartography

42.6526° N, 73.7562° W
Albany, Nueva York, United States
View in Global Crime Map

Biographical & Judicial Report

Forensic & Criminological Matrix

Parameter Forensic Detail
Forensic Heading / Aliases None
Legal Identity Lemuel Warren Smith
Confirmed Victims 6
Attributed / Indicted Victims 6
Active Timeline 1958 - 1981
Jurisdiction / Area of Operations Albany, Schenectady, Amsterdam, NY
Criminological Classification Serial Killer
Forensic Modus Operandi Strangulation, blunt force, post-mortem mutilation, bite mark evidence
Weapon / Mechanism of Death Physical force, manual strangulation
Motive / Behavioral Dynamics Multiple personality disorder, sadism
Judicial Outcome Multiple life sentences

1. Background and Profile

Born on July 23, 1941, in Amsterdam, New York, Lemuel Warren Smith grew up in a strict religious environment. His criminal history is marked by claims of multiple personality disorder and childhood trauma. Forensic evaluations noted head injuries and psychological abuse, which the defense used to argue for insanity, though he was ultimately found fit to stand trial.

2. Criminal Career and Modus Operandi

Smith's criminal activity spanned decades, involving rape, kidnapping, and murder. His modus operandi involved extreme violence and post-mortem mutilation. He was identified through advanced forensic techniques, specifically bite mark analysis and scent tracking by police dogs, which linked him to the murders of Robert Hedderman, Margaret Byron, Joan Richburg, and Maralie Wilson.

3. Investigation and Arrest

Following his 1977 arrest for the kidnapping of Marianne Maggio, investigators exhumed victims to compare bite marks. The forensic evidence provided by Dr. Michael Baden and Dr. Lowell J. Levine proved irrefutable. Smith eventually confessed to several murders, including the 1958 killing of Dorothy Waterstreet.

4. Legal Proceedings and Outcome

Smith was convicted of multiple murders and sentenced to life imprisonment. In 1981, he murdered corrections officer Donna Payant at Green Haven Correctional Facility. This crime led to a capital murder trial where he was sentenced to death in 1983. The sentence was later commuted to life imprisonment in 1984. He spent twenty years in near-isolation due to his extreme threat level.

Criminological Library & BibliographyDocumented Works

Recommended Books on Lemuel Smith

Delve into verified investigative journalism, psychiatric trial evaluations, and archival criminal profiling on this case.

Search Books on Amazon ↗
Lemuel Smith and the Compulsion To Kill
🇺🇸 English Edition

Lemuel Smith and the Compulsion To Kill

By Denis Foley

Documentary chronicle and investigative biography available in English.

Check on Amazon→
Gulliver's Travels
🇺🇸 English Edition

Gulliver's Travels

By Jonathan Swift

Documentary chronicle and investigative biography available in English.

Check on Amazon→
The Life Of Joel Chandler Harris
🇺🇸 English Edition

The Life Of Joel Chandler Harris

By Robert Lemuel Wiggins

Documentary chronicle and investigative biography available in English.

Check on Amazon→
Audible an Amazon CompanyAudible
Audible 30-Day Free Trial

Prefer audiobooks? Try Audible 30 days free

Listen to thousands of true crime podcasts, forensic memoirs, and unabridged audiobooks at no extra cost.

Claim 30-day free trial on Amazon
Cold Case Investigation Game
Real Case
Cold Case Games

Investigate Cold Cases & Mystery Escape Rooms

Experience realistic detective dossiers, crime scene evidence, interrogation transcripts, and forensic files.

Explore detective games on Amazon

Affiliate Disclosure: In accordance with the Amazon Associates Program Operating Agreement, Crimeteca earns from qualifying purchases via affiliate links. This generates no additional cost to the reader and supports the independent preservation and forensic documentation of this criminological archive.

Forensic Community Debate

Theories & Investigation Notes0

Share your hypotheses, crime scene observations or evidence insights with the Crimeteca community.

Add Your Theory / Forensic NotePosting as guest researcher
or log in →
0 / 3000
Loading debate stream...
Perfil Criminológico Comparado

Related Criminological Cases

Similar cases from the historical archive with matching criminal typology, same country, or shared modus operandi.

Edmund Kemper
IMPRISONED
10 victims

Edmund Kemper

"The Co-ed Killer, El Asesino de las Colegialas, El Gigante de Santa Cruz"

Compare Criminal
DOSSIER #02816Serial KillersChild & Juvenile Murderers

Lemuel Smith

Full / Legal Name:Lemuel Warren Smith

Confirmed Victims
6
GenderMale
BirthJuly 23, 1941 (85 years old)
Country / LocationAlbany, United States
ClassificationSerial Killers
Evidence / Photos
12 Files
Modus Operandi & Traits:Serial killer characterized by the use of blunt force, strangulation, and post-mortem mutilation. He utilized bite marks as a forensic signature and operated in both urban environments and within maximum-security correctional facilities.

Documented Victims

6 fatal

6
Fatal Victim
Female
1958-01-21Amsterdam, New York
Fatal Victim
24 yrs oldFemale
1976-12-23Colonie, New York
Fatal Victim
59 yrs oldSecretariaFemale
1976-11-24Albany, New York
Fatal Victim
48 yrs oldPropietario de tiendaMale
1976-11-24Albany, New York
Fatal Victim
30 yrs oldFemale
1977-07-22Schenectady, New York
Fatal Victim
31 yrs oldOficial penitenciariaFemale
1981-05-15Stormville, New York

Documentary Gallery

12 Files
Lemuel Smith
Perpetrator
Lemuel Smith
General
 
General

 

 
General

 

 
General

 

Newspaper headline after the trial.
General

Newspaper headline after the trial.

Photographic evidence in the Lemuel Smith dossier.
General

Photographic evidence in the Lemuel Smith dossier.

Victim associated with the Lemuel Smith case.
Victim

Victim associated with the Lemuel Smith case.

 
Victim

 

Photographic evidence in the Lemuel Smith dossier.
General

Photographic evidence in the Lemuel Smith dossier.

Bite marks on Donna Payant's body.
Crime Scene

Bite marks on Donna Payant's body.

Overlay of Smith's teeth on Donna Payant's breast.
Crime Scene

Overlay of Smith's teeth on Donna Payant's breast.

Forensic Community

Do you have theories or evidence on this dossier?

Start a public investigation thread on the forum with this dossier automatically attached.

Start forum discussion →
Santa Cruz, California, Estados Unidos
View full dossier →
Son Vu Khay Tran
IMPRISONED
4 victims

Son Vu Khay Tran

Houston, Harris County, Estados Unidos
View full dossier →
Mark Alan Smith
IMPRISONED
4 victims

Mark Alan Smith

Chicago, Illinois, Estados Unidos
View full dossier →
Craig Price
IMPRISONED
4 victims

Craig Price

"Iron Man, The Warwick Slasher"

Warwick, Rhode Island, Estados Unidos
View full dossier →