Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Full Legal Name | Martha M. Garretson Place. |
| Global Historic Landmark | First woman in world history executed in the electric chair (March 20, 1899). |
| Criminological Typology | Intrafamilial homicidal assault / Severe stepmother jealousy / Acid attack and positional suffocation. |
| Date of Crime | February 7, 1898. |
| Crime Scene | Family residence at 755 Chauncey Street, Brooklyn, New York, United States. |
| Fatal Victim | Ida Place (aged 17), Martha's stepdaughter. |
| Surviving Victim | William W. Place (husband, attacked with an axe). |
| Weapons | Concentrated nitric acid splashed onto eyes/mouth, pillow/bedsheet suffocation, and a small hand axe. |
| Judicial Penalty | Capital execution via electrocution. Executed by Edwin Davis at Sing Sing Prison (Ossining, New York) on March 20, 1899. |
Background and Traumatic Head Injury
Martha Garretson was born in Millstone, New Jersey, on September 18, 1849. At age 23, she suffered a severe closed-head traumatic injury when struck by a heavy sled, an incident to which relatives attributed a dramatic, permanent shift in temperament toward volatile paranoia and erratic outbursts.
In 1893, she took employment as a housekeeper for William W. Place, a prosperous widower in Brooklyn raising his young daughter Ida. William soon married Martha, but the household was besieged by continuous domestic conflict: Martha conceived an intense, jealous hatred toward stepdaughter Ida, whose youth and affectionate bond with her father provoked Martha's violent resentment.
The Chauncey Street Tragedy (February 1898)
On the morning of February 7, 1898, following a bitter morning quarrel with her husband, Martha put her revenge into motion. Ascending to the second-floor bedroom where 17-year-old Ida was resting, Martha attacked the teen.
She poured a bottle of concentrated nitric acid across Ida's face and eyes, causing devastating chemical burns and blinding her. As the girl writhed in pain, Martha smothered her with pillows and bedclothes until respiration ceased.
Concealing Ida's corpse beneath the mattress, Martha retrieved an axe and lay in wait in the dark ground-floor entryway. When William Place unlocked the door at 6:30 PM, Martha ambushed him, hacking him repeatedly across the scalp and shoulders. Despite extensive skull lacerations, William disarmed her and staggered into the street crying for help.
Police officers arrived to find Martha unconscious on the parlor floor, having opened gas jets in a failed suicide attempt. Upstairs, detectives uncovered Ida's chemically scorched corpse.
Brooklyn Trial and Governor Theodore Roosevelt
Martha Place was tried in Kings County Court in July 1898. Counsel argued legal insanity caused by her early traumatic brain injury. Crown alienists testified that her purchase of nitric acid days in advance and the calculated evening ambush demonstrated deliberate malice aforethought.
She was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death. The sentence ignited heated debate nationwide regarding the propriety of executing a female inmate in the newly adopted electric chair. New York Governor Theodore Roosevelt firmly denied clemency, maintaining that equal justice under the law demanded that capital sentences be executed irrespective of gender.
Sing Sing Electrocution (March 1899)
On the morning of March 20, 1899, Martha Place was escorted into the death chamber at Sing Sing Prison holding a small Bible. A specialized black dress had been tailored to accommodate the leg electrode.
State electrician Edwin Davis administered 1,760 volts of electricity. Death was instantaneous, sealing Martha Place's status in criminal history as the first woman to die in the electric chair.








