Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Forensic Heading / Aliases | Carole Tregoff |
| Legal Identity | Carole Tregoff |
| Confirmed Victims | 1 (Barbara Jean Finch) |
| Active Timeline | 1958 - 1959 |
| Jurisdiction / Area of Operations | West Covina, California, USA |
| Criminological Classification | Contract murder conspiracy / Passion-driven homicide |
| Forensic Modus Operandi | Initial attempted solicitation of hitmen (John Patrick Cody) followed by direct armed confrontation and homicide at victim's residence |
| Weapon / Mechanism of Death | Firearms (.38-caliber revolver) |
| Motive / Behavioral Dynamics | Financial gain (avoiding ruin under California community property laws) and romantic permanence |
| Judicial Outcome | Convicted of second-degree murder on March 27, 1961; sentenced to 5 years to life. Paroled on April 29, 1969 |
1. Background and Profile
Carole Tregoff was born around 1939. At age twenty, she worked as a medical receptionist in California, where she met Dr. Bernard Finch, a wealthy and successful 42-year-old Los Angeles surgeon. Tregoff was separated from her first husband, Jimmy Pappa, while Finch was married to Barbara Jean Finch, residing in an opulent home with an estimated fortune of $750,000. The extramarital relationship quickly escalated into a high-stakes dynamic driven by passion and material ambition.
2. Crime Spree and Modus Operandi
As the affair deepened, Finch sought to legitimize their union. However, California's stringent community property laws meant that a divorce prompted by adultery would cost Finch half of his wealth. Unwilling to accept financial ruin, Finch and Tregoff devised a conspiracy. They traveled to Las Vegas and attempted to hire criminals, including self-confessed gigolo and ex-convict John Patrick Cody, paying him to seduce and subsequently murder Barbara Jean Finch. After Cody took the money and failed to execute the crime, the couple resorted to direct intervention.
3. Investigation and Forensic Hunt
On July 18, 1959, Bernard Finch and Carole Tregoff arrived at the Finch residence on Lark Hill Drive in West Covina. When Barbara Jean Finch drove up, a violent struggle ensued, culminating in her death from a .38-caliber gunshot wound to the chest. While Finch fled to Las Vegas, Tregoff hid on the property before escaping separately. Law enforcement quickly closed in on the pair, aided by testimonies from household staff and disclosures from John Patrick Cody regarding the murder-for-hire plot.
4. Legal Proceedings and Trial
The sensational trial captured national headlines due to its mixture of greed, social status, and melodrama. The first two trials ended in mistrials due to deadlocked juries. A third trial, commencing in January 1961 before Superior Judge David Coleman, concluded on March 27, 1961, when a jury convicted Bernard Finch of first-degree murder and Carole Tregoff of second-degree murder.
5. Psychiatric Assessment and Outcome
Both defendants were sentenced to life imprisonment in California state penitentiaries. Tregoff distanced herself from Finch during incarceration, spurning his letters. After serving eight years, Tregoff was paroled on April 29, 1969. She subsequently changed her name, secured employment at a Pasadena area hospital, and successfully reintegrated into civilian life.


































