Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Forensic Heading / Aliases | The Killer of Amy Schulz |
| Legal Identity | Cecil S. Sutherland |
| Confirmed Victims | 1 (Amy Schulz) |
| Attributed / Indicted Victims | 1 |
| Active Timeline | July 1, 1987 |
| Jurisdiction / Area of Operations | Jefferson County and Marion County, Illinois, United States |
| Criminological Classification | Opportunistic pedophilic predator, sexual sadist, child murderer |
| Forensic Modus Operandi | Daytime/evening vehicular abduction of an unaccompanied child, manual strangulation, anorectal assault, deep neck transection, and postmortem thoracic stomp compression |
| Weapon / Mechanism of Death | Non-serrated sharp instrument (hunting blade), blunt force trauma, manual strangulation, and massive exsanguination |
| Motive / Behavioral Dynamics | Sadistic-sexual gratification, predatory pedophilia, and destructive antisocial pathology |
| Judicial Outcome | Sentenced to death in 1989; convictions overturned in 2000 due to ineffective assistance of trial counsel; retried and sentenced to death in 2004; commuted to life imprisonment without parole following Illinois capital abolition in 2011 |
1. Background and Profile
Cecil S. Sutherland was born on May 28, 1955, and spent much of his adult life in rural Southern Illinois. In the late 1980s, he resided with his elderly parents in the village of Dix, situated in Jefferson County. Standing 6 feet 3 inches tall and weighing between 250 and 260 pounds, Sutherland possessed an imposing physical frame. He worked as an industrial laborer at a manufacturing plant in Mt. Vernon, Illinois, adhering to an ordinary morning shift schedule from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.
Beneath a facade of low-profile rural existence, Sutherland harbored deeply aberrant psychosexual fixations and an inclination toward violence. Prior to the capital prosecution, offers of proof revealed that a former stepson reported being subjected to repetitive anorectal sodomy by Sutherland when the child was approximately six years old. Sutherland operated a distinctive tan 1977 Plymouth Fury automobile and frequently transported his pet black Labrador retriever, named "Babe"—two forensic vectors that ultimately formed the cornerstone of physical trace evidence that tied him to one of Illinois' most notorious child homicides.
2. Criminal Career and Modus Operandi
On the summer evening of July 1, 1987, in the quiet village of Kell, Illinois (Marion County), 10-year-old Amy Schulz returned home after helping her father, Dennis Schulz, at his vacuum repair business in Salem. After preparing dinner, Dennis Schulz handed Amy a flashlight and asked her to walk north along Jefferson Street to locate her brother Ryan, who was searching for a stray family dog named "Biscuit." Amy stopped briefly at her step-grandparents' home around 8:30 p.m. and continued walking south on Jefferson Street, where neighbors last sighted her between 9:10 p.m. and 9:15 p.m.
Five to ten minutes later, local witnesses spotted an older-model tan automobile traveling south at high speed along the same deserted roadway. Cecil Sutherland abducted Amy from the street, forcing her into his passenger compartment, and transported her approximately 12 miles south into an isolated oil lease access road in rural Jefferson County. The crime scene was located less than a half-mile from the former residence of the Hufford family, into which two of Sutherland's brothers had married, confirming his intimate familiarity with the labyrinthine backroads.
Upon reaching the desolate petroleum easement, Sutherland enacted a frenzied, sadistic assault. Medical and pathomorphological analysis showed that Amy was manually choked into unconsciousness, fracturing her larynx. The perpetrator then committed violent perimortem anorectal sodomy. Sutherland subsequently severed the victim's throat with an incised wound measuring 14.5 centimeters in length, using a non-serrated linear knife blade. The deep laceration completely transected the right internal jugular vein and common carotid artery, terminating behind the right ear and cutting into the intervertebral cartilage between the C4 and C5 vertebrae. To accelerate exsanguination, Sutherland brutally stomped on the child's back with his heavy boot, leaving clear sole impressions, fracturing her first right rib, and splitting her liver nearly in two from severe postmortem torso compression.
3. Investigation and Arrest
On the morning of July 2, 1987, an oil-field worker discovered Amy Schulz's nude, dust-covered corpse lying prone in a large pool of blood on the oil lease road. Illinois State Police crime-scene technician Richard Caudell secured the location, lifting tire track plaster impressions within 17 feet of the body and boot tread impressions from both the ground and the victim's bare skin. Autopsy procedures conducted by Dr. Steven Nuernberger recovered two pubic hairs lodged in the fecal matter of the victim's rectal area and buttocks, alongside multiple pet guard hairs and rare red synthetic fabric fibers.
Forensic scientist David Brundage of the Illinois State Police determined that the tire casts matched only two bias-belted models manufactured across North America: the Cooper Falls Persuader and Dean Polaris. Footwear impression analysis confirmed that the outsole pattern belonged to a "Texas Steer" work boot sold exclusively by Kmart. Microscopic analysis led by forensic examiner Kenneth Knight eliminated Amy's family members, her step-grandfather William Willis (a convicted sex offender investigated as an alternate suspect), and 24 other men.
The investigation stalled until October 1987, when federal authorities in Montana flagged Sutherland through the FBI's VICAP system. On October 10, 1987, National Park Service rangers discovered Sutherland's 1977 Plymouth Fury abandoned in Glacier National Park with a handwritten note bequeathing the vehicle to his parents. On October 21, 1987, federal rangers apprehended Sutherland after an armed confrontation in which he fired shots at a park ranger, for which he subsequently pleaded guilty in federal court to attempted murder of a federal officer. Montana rangers noted that Sutherland had a Cooper Falls Persuader tire mounted on the right-front position of his abandoned car and Texas Steer boots in his duffle bag. Illinois detectives flew to Missoula County, executed search warrants, acquired biological exemplars, and impounded the vehicle.
4. Legal Proceedings and Outcome
Laboratory examinations of Sutherland's Plymouth Fury yielded an extraordinary physical match: nineteen red fibers recovered from the front passenger carpet and seat were microscopically and chemically identical to the rare, non-commercial multilobe polyester and cotton fabrics used in Amy's homemade shorts and shirt. In reciprocal fashion, twenty-eight gold carpet fibers and a gold tuft lifted from Amy's clothing matched the proprietary automotive carpeting manufactured exclusively by J.P. Stevens for 1977–1978 Chrysler models. Additionally, 32 dog hairs on the child's clothes matched Sutherland's black Labrador, Babe, through mitochondrial DNA sequencing conducted by QuestGen Forensics.
In June 1988, Sutherland was indicted in Jefferson County for aggravated kidnapping, aggravated criminal sexual assault, and first-degree murder. Following a change of venue to Richland County, a jury convicted him on all counts in 1989 and imposed a sentence of death. However, in November 2000, the Illinois Supreme Court overturned the convictions (People v. Sutherland, 194 Ill. 2d 289), holding that original defense counsel provided ineffective assistance by failing to investigate and present evidence showing Sutherland may have obtained the boots and tire after the date of the homicide.
A second trial convened in May 2004 in St. Clair County. Prosecutors bolstered the case with sophisticated mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequencing performed by Mitotyping Technologies under Dr. Terry Melton. The two pubic hairs recovered from Amy's rectal crease matched Sutherland's maternal genetic lineage, exhibiting an mtDNA sequence found in fewer than 0.06% of the North American Caucasian population. Following five weeks of testimony, the jury found Sutherland guilty on all charges. In an atypical tactical move, Sutherland waived his right to a second-stage sentencing hearing and joined the prosecution in submitting an agreed recommendation for capital punishment to expedite direct review by the state supreme court. The trial judge sentenced him to death.
The Illinois Supreme Court affirmed the conviction and sentence on direct appeal (Docket No. 99047), establishing an execution date of March 13, 2007. However, capital execution was stayed pending ongoing post-conviction litigation. In March 2011, Illinois Governor Pat Quinn signed landmark legislation abolishing the death penalty statewide and commuting all remaining capital sentences to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. Cecil Sutherland remains incarcerated in the maximum-security system of the Illinois Department of Corrections.









