Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Full Identity | Donn A. Duncan |
| Birth | September 25, 1945 |
| Location | Orange County, Florida, USA |
| Crimes | 1969 (Willie Davis) / December 29, 1990 (Deborah Bauer) |
| Fatal Victims | Willie Davis and Deborah Bauer (30) |
| Method | Axe blow to the head (1969) / Kitchen knife stabbing (1990) |
| Legal Disposition | 1991 death sentence vacated; serving life imprisonment |
1. Prior Prison Murder & 1990 Attack
In 1969, Donn A. Duncan was convicted of second-degree murder for killing fellow Florida inmate Willie Davis with an axe blow to the head. Years later, on December 29, 1990, after an argument the previous evening in Orange County, Duncan concealed a kitchen knife in his jacket, walked onto the front porch where his fiancée Deborah Bauer (30) was smoking, and stabbed her fatally in the back and chest before threatening her daughter and waiting for police.
2. Sentencing & Resentencing
Duncan gave a signed confession and was sentenced to death on August 30, 1991, following a unanimous jury recommendation. His death sentence was later vacated in post-conviction proceedings, leaving him serving life imprisonment.









