Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Full Identity | John Dell Carr |
| Birth | 1962 |
| Location | Shelby and Hamilton Counties, Indiana, USA |
| Crime Period | October 6, 1990 – July 4, 1991 |
| Fatal Victims | Shirley F. Sturgill (42) and Barbara Foote (32) |
| Method | Manual strangulation, sexual assault, bite marks, and arson |
| Legal Disposition | Sentenced to 80 years (1992) and 60 years (1997) in Indiana |
1. The Murder of Shirley Sturgill
Late on October 6, 1990, firefighters forced entry into the locked Shelby County apartment of Shirley F. Sturgill (42) and extinguished a bedroom fire, discovering her strangled body bearing bite marks on her thighs and severe mutilation. Charges against a neighbor were dismissed in May 1991.
2. Second Killing & Convictions
Following the July 4, 1991 strangulation murder of Barbara Foote (32), Carr was sentenced to 80 years in prison on May 29, 1992. In 1994, his former wife Angie Carr informed detectives of his suspicious return and immediate laundering of clothes on the night of her mother's death. After dental impressions were taken, Carr was convicted in 1997 of murdering Sturgill and sentenced to 60 years, a judgment affirmed by the Indiana Supreme Court in April 2000.







