Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Full Legal Name | William Andrews |
| Legal Identity | William Andrews |
| Media / Judicial Moniker | The Ogden Hi-Fi Shop Murders |
| Date of Birth | April 19, 1954 |
| Place of Birth | Missouri, United States |
| Date of Execution | July 30, 1992 (aged 38) |
| Place of Execution | Utah State Prison, Draper, Utah |
| Legal Cause of Death | Judicial execution by lethal injection |
| Procedural Status | Executed following conviction for three counts of first-degree capital murder |
| Fatal Victims | 3 (Sherry Michelle Ansley, 18; Byron Keith Naisbitt, 16; Stanley Walker, 20) |
| Surviving Severely Injured | 2 victims (Cortney Naisbitt and Orrene Walker) |
| Criminological Classification | Commercial robbery with sadistic chemical torture and hostage execution |
| Primary Trigging Accomplice | Dale Selby Pierre (executed by lethal injection/firing squad in 1987) |
| Chemical Agent & Weapons | Caustic sodium hydroxide drain cleaner (Liquid Plumr) and .25 caliber handgun |
Criminological Profile & Background
William Andrews was an active-duty airman in the United States Air Force stationed at Hill Air Force Base near Ogden, Utah. Alongside fellow serviceman Dale Selby Pierre, Andrews engaged in planning armed robberies against regional commercial outlets to seize high-end stereo equipment, currency, and vehicles.
Borrowing tactical concepts from violent action movies, the pair procured handguns, duct tape, and a bottle of heavy-duty caustic drain opener (Liquid Plumr), having formulated a predetermined protocol to eliminate all potential witnesses.
The Hi-Fi Stereo Murders: April 22, 1974
On the evening of April 22, 1974, Andrews and Pierre entered the Hi-Fi Stereo shop in Ogden shortly before closing time. At gunpoint, they seized store clerk Stanley Walker (aged 20) and customer Michelle Ansley (aged 18), forcing them down the basement stairs.
Over the next half hour, three additional individuals entered the shop searching for family members: sixteen-year-old Cortney Naisbitt, his mother Orrene Walker Naisbitt (aged 43), and sixteen-year-old Byron Keith Naisbitt. All five were bound with duct tape in the basement.
In the basement, Andrews poured the highly corrosive caustic chemical solution (Liquid Plumr) into plastic cups and coerced the bound hostages into swallowing it under the guise of an oral tranquilizer. The caustic agent instantly produced severe internal and external chemical burns, blistering the victims' lips, tongues, and vocal cords. While Andrews hauled stereo gear into their vehicle above, Pierre executed the victims, shooting each in the back of the head with a .25 caliber semi-automatic pistol.
Three hostages died of catastrophic ballistic and chemical trauma. Cortney Naisbitt survived miraculously despite profound, permanent neurological and cognitive injuries.
Judicial Proceedings, Appeals, and Execution
The investigation tracked the stolen merchandise back to Hill Air Force Base after fellow airmen informed civilian authorities that Andrews and Pierre were attempting to sell new stereo components out of their barracks.
In November 1974, a Weber County jury found Andrews and Pierre guilty of three counts of first-degree capital murder and aggravated robbery, returning death sentences. Although Andrews litigated extensive federal habeas corpus appeals alleging he had not fired the fatal bullets, courts consistently upheld his joint liability, noting his direct role in administering the caustic chemical torture and managing the lethal robbery.
Dale Selby Pierre was executed in Utah in August 1987. On July 30, 1992, William Andrews was executed by lethal injection at the Utah State Prison in Draper.







