Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Full Legal Name | Kimberly Sue Anderson (née Miller) |
| Court Case Identifier | State of Ohio v. Kimberly S. Anderson (Auglaize County Common Pleas Court) |
| Criminological Classification | Spousal shooting, disputed self-defense in domestic environment |
| Date & Location of Incident | September 2, 2001, Wapakoneta, Auglaize County, Ohio, USA |
| Confirmed Deceased | 1 (Brent Anderson, aged 39, divorce attorney) |
| Weapon Utilized | 9 mm semi-automatic handgun |
| Dispute Etiology | Escalated domestic altercation amidst contentious divorce and child custody battle |
| Criminal Verdict | Acquitted of aggravated murder by jury verdict (self-defense) in November 2002 |
| Civil Verdict | Found civilly liable for wrongful death in June 2005; awarded $540,000+ in damages |
Background and Contextual Friction
Kimberly Sue Anderson was the defendant in a landmark high-profile domestic shooting case in Auglaize County, Ohio. Kimberly was married to Brent Anderson, a prominent local attorney with a substantial domestic relations and family law practice. Together they shared two children and resided in a suburban neighborhood of Wapakoneta.
By the summer of 2001, the marital relationship had fractured completely into bitter mutual accusations, emotional distress, and contentious preparations for divorce proceedings. At the core of the dispute was a battle over legal and residential custody of their children, creating severe psychological friction inside the household.
The Shooting of Brent Anderson
On the evening of September 2, 2001, an altercation erupted inside the master bedroom. According to Kimberly's official statements, Brent approached her in an aggressive and physically threatening manner, putting her in immediate apprehension of severe bodily harm. Kimberly retrieved a 9 mm semi-automatic firearm kept in the residence and discharged a single round into Brent's chest.
Emergency responders arrived shortly after a 911 emergency call, pronouncing Brent Anderson dead at the scene from acute hemorrhagic shock. Auglaize County Sheriff deputies arrested Kimberly Anderson without incident and booked her on charges of aggravated murder.
Criminological Analysis and Divergent Legal Verdicts
The legal proceedings unfolded across two distinct jurisdictions with opposing outcomes:
- The Criminal Trial (2002): The defense presented evidence depicting a pattern of domestic intimidation and argued justifiable self-defense under Ohio law. On November 20, 2002, the twelve-person jury accepted the defense narrative that Kimberly reasonably believed lethal force was necessary to avert imminent death or great bodily harm, returning a full acquittal on all criminal counts.
- The Civil Wrongful Death Trial (2005): Brent Anderson's estate and surviving kin filed a wrongful death action. Under the lower burden of proof applicable in civil torts (preponderance of the evidence), the civil jury determined that Kimberly's application of lethal firearm force was unreasonable and unlawful under the specific physical circumstances, awarding over $540,000 in damages against her.











