Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Full Legal Name | Shari Lee Tobyne |
| Legal Identity | Shari Lee Tobyne |
| Date of Birth | October 14, 1964 |
| Place of Birth | Clifton, Kansas, United States |
| Date of Death | August 20, 2011 (aged 46) |
| Place of Death | Estrella Jail, Maricopa County, Phoenix, Arizona |
| Legal Cause of Death | Suicide in custody prior to trial |
| Procedural Status | Deceased by suicide while detained on first-degree murder charges |
| Proven Victims | 1 (Dwight Tobyne, aged 57) |
| Criminological Classification | Premeditated spousal murder / Post-mortem dismemberment and dispersal |
| Motive | Impending marital separation and marital asset dissolution |
| Modus Operandi | Gunshot homicide following firearm acquisition and marksmanship training, followed by body dismemberment |
| Key Physical Evidence | Multi-county DNA matches and recovery of discarded handgun and clothing from a commercial dumpster |
Criminological Profile & Background
Shari Lee and Dwight Tobyne grew up on adjoining family farms in rural Clifton, Kansas, marrying and raising three adult children. In 2004, the couple relocated to the desert Southwest, purchasing a home in Scottsdale, Arizona.
By late 2009, marital relations had collapsed irreversibly. Fifty-seven-year-old Dwight Tobyne announced his definitive intention to dissolve the marriage and relocate back to the Midwest at the end of November 2009.
Confronted with the prospect of divorce and property division, Shari Tobyne initiated clear preparations: in early November 2009, she purchased a handgun and visited a local shooting range to learn handling and target accuracy, establishing clear evidence of planning.
Homicide and Disposal of Remains
In late November 2009, Dwight Tobyne vanished abruptly. When their adult children questioned his absence through Thanksgiving, Christmas, and the birth of a grandchild, Shari claimed he had abruptly departed for Mexico to start anew.
However, cellular tower tracking contradicted her narrative, revealing Dwight's phone pinging within the Phoenix metropolitan area in December. In July 2010, the couple's children formally contacted the Scottsdale Police Department to file a missing person report.
Investigators recovered Dwight's abandoned pickup truck in an apartment parking lot. Placing Shari under physical surveillance, detectives observed her disposing of a garbage bag in a commercial dumpster. Upon examination, the bag contained clothing and the handgun she had purchased in November 2009.
Forensic Identifications and In-Custody Suicide
In December 2009, outdoor enthusiasts had independently discovered dismembered human body parts scattered in remote desert terrain across three separate Arizona counties. The Arizona Department of Public Safety crime lab developed an STR DNA profile from the remains. In October 2010, following comparison with Dwight Tobyne's reference standards, forensic scientists confirmed a definitive genetic match.
Under interrogation, Shari claimed the firearm discharged accidentally while Dwight allegedly attempted to stop her from committing suicide, and asserted she dismembered and concealed the remains out of fear that law enforcement would not believe her.
A Maricopa County grand jury indicted Shari Tobyne on charges of first-degree premeditated murder and abandonment of a dead human body. On August 20, 2011, while remanded in custody at the Estrella Jail awaiting psychiatric competency evaluations and trial, Shari Tobyne committed suicide in her cell.











