Alyssa Bustamante: The Thrill Killing and the St. Martins Blood Diary
Executive Summary
Alyssa Dailene Bustamante (born January 28, 1994) is an American convicted murderer who, at age 15, perpetrated the brutal premeditated murder of her 9-year-old neighbor, Elizabeth Olten, in the rural community of St. Martins, Missouri. The crime, committed on October 21, 2009, shocked the international public not only due to the youth of both victim and perpetrator, but because of the callous motivation behind it: Bustamante confessed to investigators that she planned and executed the homicide out of morbid curiosity, simply wanting to "know what it felt like to kill someone."
Days earlier, during a school recess, the teenager had dug two shallow graves in a dense wooded area near her home. On the afternoon of the crime, using the established neighborly trust and employing her younger sister as an unwitting decoy, Bustamante lured Elizabeth into the woods promising a "surprise gift." There, she attacked the child with extreme ferocity: beating her, strangling her with her bare hands, and inflicting multiple stab wounds to her chest and wrists before slitting her throat with a kitchen knife. After burying the body under dirt and brush, she returned home, changed clothes, and attended a youth church dance.
That same evening, Alyssa recorded a chilling confession in her personal journal, which she later attempted to conceal under blue ink: «I just killed someone [...] It was amazing. As soon as you get over the 'oh my god, I can't do this' feeling, it's pretty enjoyable». Following a massive 45-hour search by law enforcement and volunteers, Bustamante confessed and led FBI agents and Missouri State Highway Patrol officers to the hidden grave. Originally indicted for first-degree murder, she entered a guilty plea in January 2012 to second-degree murder and armed criminal action. She was sentenced to life imprisonment with eligibility for parole plus a consecutive 30-year sentence, requiring a minimum of 35 years and five months of actual incarceration at the Chillicothe Correctional Center before her first parole consideration.
Forensic & Criminological Matrix
| Parameter | Forensic Detail |
|---|---|
| Legal Identity | Alyssa Dailene Bustamante |
| Digital Alias | "OkamiKage" (Japanese for WolfShadow) |
| Date of Birth | January 28, 1994 (Cole County, Missouri, U.S.) |
| Age at Crime | 15 years and 8 months (certified to stand trial as an adult) |
| Fatal Victim | Elizabeth Olten (9 years old; neighbor and playmate) |
| Date of Crime | October 21, 2009 (approx. between 18:15 and 19:00 CDT) |
| Primary Crime Scene | Forested tract west of St. Martins, Cole County, Missouri |
| Disposal Site | Pre-dug clandestine woodland grave concealed beneath timber and foliage |
| Modus Operandi | Luring via deception; manual strangulation, chest stab wounds, and incised throat laceration |
| Weapons Employed | Bare hands and smooth-edge household kitchen knife |
| Criminological Motive | Thrill killing / Morbid experimental curiosity |
| Forensic Psychiatric Profile | Major depressive disorder, borderline personality disorder, chronic history of severe cutting |
| Key Inculpatory Evidence | Hand-written journal entry deciphered via forensic spectral imaging |
| Judicial Disposition | Sentenced February 8, 2012: Life with parole (2nd-degree murder) + 30 consecutive years (armed criminal action) |
| Current Incarceration | Chillicothe Correctional Center (Livingston County, Missouri) |
Family Environment and Prior Pathology
Alyssa Bustamante grew up in a profoundly dysfunctional domestic environment. She was born to a teenage mother, Michelle, who struggled with substance abuse and accumulated multiple arrests. Her biological father, Caesar Bustamante, served a ten-year prison term for armed assault during Alyssa's childhood. Consequently, legal guardianship was granted to her maternal grandparents, Gary and Karen Brooke, in the rural town of St. Martins near Jefferson City.
Despite a religious upbringing and satisfactory academic marks, Alyssa manifested severe psychiatric disturbance from age 11:
- Chronic Self-Harm: She possessed over 300 cutting scars across her limbs, deliberate cigarette burns, and the word "hate" carved into her skin.
- Suicide Attempt & Medication: In 2007, she attempted suicide via an overdose of painkillers, prompting inpatient hospitalization and ongoing prescriptions for fluoxetina (Prozac). Her dosage had been increased two weeks prior to the murder.
- Macabre Digital Footprint: On her YouTube account under the handle OkamiKage, she listed her hobbies as "cutting and killing people". In one video, she filmed her 9-year-old twin brothers touching an electric fence, inserting text: "this is where it gets good, this is where we see my brothers get hurt".
Premeditation: The Woodland Graves
The murder was not an impulsive outburst. Days prior to October 21, 2009, during school holidays, Alyssa entered the dense woods behind her home with a shovel and dug two shallow trenches.
Behavioral analysts from the FBI later theorized that the existence of two separate graves suggested her original intended targets may have been her two younger brothers, before seizing an opportunistic chance to kill Elizabeth Olten. After digging the pits, she concealed the shovel and waited.
The Murder of Elizabeth Olten (October 21, 2009)
The victim, 9-year-old Elizabeth Olten, lived four hundred yards away. A shy child who was terrified of the dark, she spent the afternoon playing with Alyssa's 6-year-old half-sister.
Around 18:15, as Elizabeth started walking home, Alyssa intercepted her and coaxed her into the woods with the promise of a surprise gift:
- The Physical Assault: At the grave site, Alyssa knocked Elizabeth to the ground and strangled her with bare hands.
- Edged Weapon Attack: When the child continued to whimper, Alyssa drew a kitchen knife from her backpack, inflicting stab wounds to her chest and wrists before delivering a deep transverse laceration across her throat, severing the trachea and carotid vessels.
- Burial: She dragged the body into the grave, covered it with dirt, and arranged pine branches and dead leaves to camouflage the site.
- Immediate Search: Within 45 minutes of Elizabeth failing to return, her mother reported her missing at 19:00, knowing Elizabeth would never enter the woods at dusk voluntarily.
The Diary Confession and Recovery
While search parties, bloodhounds, helicopters, and FBI agents combed the terrain in freezing rain, Alyssa Bustamante displayed total composure: she cleaned up, hid the knife, and attended a church dance.
Returning to her room that midnight, she penned the central evidence of the case:
"I just murdered someone. I strangled them and slit their throat and stabbed them now they are dead. I don't know how to feel at the moment. It was amazing. As soon as you get over the 'oh my god I can't do this' feeling, it's pretty enjoyable. I'm kinda nervous and shaky though right now. Kay, I gotta go to church now… lol."
Bustamante subsequently smeared blue ink over the page to obliterate the writing. However, forensic document examiner Don Locke restored the complete text utilizing spectral imaging and infrared reflectography.
On October 23, confronted with inconsistencies during interrogation and the deciphered diary, Bustamante broke down and led detectives to the grave. Search teams had previously walked within yards of the burial site, fooled by the dense camouflage.
Legal Proceedings and Sentence
In November 2009, the court ruled Bustamante would be tried as an adult.
Defense attorneys Charlie Moreland and Gary Brotherton argued the homicide resulted from Prozac-induced behavioral toxicity acting upon adolescent depression. However, Cole County Prosecutor Mark Richardson countered by proving extensive premeditation through the pre-dug graves and triumphant journal entries.
On January 10, 2012, to avoid mandatory life without parole, Bustamante pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and armed criminal action.
On February 8, 2012, Circuit Judge Patricia Joyce imposed sentence:
- Life imprisonment with eligibility for parole for second-degree murder.
- A consecutive 30-year prison sentence for armed criminal action.
Under Missouri statutory sentencing guidelines, Bustamante must serve at least 35 years and five months of actual prison time before her earliest parole hearing in 2045, when she will be over 51 years old. She remains incarcerated at Chillicothe Correctional Center.




































































